The Gift

i-8b3c71b2953197893ab8588bd58e3fa3-thegift200x302.jpg

BOOK NAME: The Gift: Witch & Wizard Book 2
AUTHOR: James Patterson

I hope all of you know who the author James Patterson is. If not, abandon the computer and get one of your parents to take you to the bookstore ASAP. But while you’re there, don’t pick up The Gift. I’ve already made that mistake.

Okay, okay, it wasn’t THAT bad. Let me start at the beginning: I’m normally a huge Patterson fan, but when I picked up Witch and Wizard (the book before The Gift), I was a little disappointed because it was only mediocre. It was an okay plot and everything, but the way it was written was not as appealing as it could have been. Despite this, when the sequel (The Gift) came out, I went right to my local Barnes and Noble, bought it, and read it. Now, a few hours later, I’m still in a state of confusion.

Before we get into why I didn’t like it, I’ll give a little background. Whit and Wisteria Allgood are just normal teenagers until they discover they have magical powers when the New Order is established (basically, all of the job titles start with “The One” and they hate anyone who isn’t into the whole “kill people who look like they don’t like us” thing). That was the first book, in which they engage in many adventures, live in an old department store, and use magic. The Gift is the second book in the series, and follows Whit and Wisty again as they engage in even more fun adventures, sometimes involving chocolate and inevitably ending in meeting “The One Who is The One.” Don’t worry, I’m confused, too.

Basically, my problems with the book were these: James Patterson and his coauthor (conveniently listed in barely-visible print at the bottom of the dust cover) tried WAY too hard to get the teen language and vibe right–I mean, I never say ‘totes cool.’ Also, the plot was not as great as it could have been. We’ve all seen post-apocalyptic new world government stuff before, and we’ve also seen magic. But mix them together in a generic plot line, and what do you get? Not a good book, I can tell you that.

Before you forgo reading this, remember that this is only my opinion and I tend to be pretty tough on books. If you have read it, comment back and tell me what you thought!

Comments

  1. jindo2108
    May 20, 2011, 3:41 pm

    First of all…..AWESOME review, Mairen! Loved it:).
    Anyway…
    I do know who James Patterson is, but I’ve never read any of his books (including this one).
    Don’t think I’ll read this one. I get really frustrated with confusing plots:)…doesn’t seem like my type of book(even though I like fantasy)\
    Yeah.
    Anyone here read it?

  2. sembalion
    May 21, 2011, 1:02 am

    okkkkkkkkkkkkkkk…………………..anyway…i’m not getting it.1st….and last……i am not a teen

  3. zerty111
    May 21, 2011, 10:42 am

    I agree. this book wasn’t that good, his maximum ride books are way better. They’re part of the reason I bought the book.

  4. ballerinagirl
    May 23, 2011, 10:45 am

    ugh yah i agree with you some people try to hard to speak like a teen and the truth is we dont actually speak like thart thats just in the movies ! ! haha . i dont do magic myself . i did love the narnia series have any of you guys read that . they were awsome . the last battle was intense for those of you who like a reall thrill

  5. irishlad
    May 24, 2011, 3:17 pm

    WHAT!! I loved this book and I didnt even know there was first one until now.I cant even remember any ‘cool’ teen words but its been a while since I read it. I agree with you about no magic. I would have loved it without magic

  6. dre chulo 33
    May 26, 2011, 2:18 pm

    what it do i’ve never read this book but i would love to one day i’ve read one of your books and been hooked the first one i read was lifegaurd and it was alsome

  7. dre chulo 33
    May 26, 2011, 2:18 pm

    what it do i’ve never read this book but i would love to one day i’ve read one of your books and been hooked the first one i read was lifegaurd and it was alsome

  8. Natedog6
    May 29, 2011, 2:48 pm

    I love james patterson and your right they did try to hard to teenage vie right, but other than that i think that the wicth and wizard/the gift were both good books. not great bu still good books

  9. titanic524
    June 1, 2011, 3:41 pm

    I agree that it wasn’t as good as Patterson other books, but I still enjoyed it (& the prelude. I read this a couple months ago, so I may be mistaken but I didn’t think they tried to hard to get a “teenager vibe”. However the languge and actions are kinda fake.

  10. BooksandPuppies
    June 10, 2011, 11:00 am

    I personally loved this book. I thought the plot was, yes, confusing, but it all came together. I did a book report on The Gift, and it turned out great. Everyone seemed like they thought the book sounded good. Personally, I think that the Witch & Wizard series is better than the Maximum Ride books. Overall, I enjoyed this book a lot.

  11. love art\acting :]
    June 17, 2011, 2:38 pm

    my sister read this book,the first(witch and wizard),maximum ride,and danil x.she loves all of them.

  12. Redwall0071
    February 4, 2012, 10:43 pm

    I LOVE JAMES PATTERSON!!!!!! Have any of you read his new book that just came out, Middle school: the worst years of my life? It’s pretty good

  13. TrixieRockyCrystal101
    March 26, 2012, 11:21 am

    For 1 I am not a teen. For 2 I LOVE MAGIC SOMEONE GIVE ME A SPELL FOR MAKING ME A MERMAID WHEN I WANNNA!

  14. mizoreangel2000
    June 18, 2012, 11:09 am

    A classmate of mine read this book. She said it was OK. I don’t plan on reading this book; it doesn’t look terribly good.

You must be logged in to post a comment.